Sheepfarmer’s Daughter by Elizabeth Moon (The Deed of Paksenarrion)

Synopsis:
A country girl enlists as a recruit in a band of mercenary soldiers, where she excels–and may be receiving supernatural aid from a saint she doesn’t know about or believe in.

Review:
Oddly enough, Sheepfarmer’s Daughter reminded me a lot of Battlestar Galactica, with its preoccupations over military honor and what makes for goodness in wartime. And anyone who knows me will let you know that this is a compliment of the highest order.

There are no starships or robots in the first book of the Deed of Paksenarrion, of course–this is epic fantasy of the Tolkien strain, complete with elves and dwarves. I hope Elizabeth Moon has reinvented these creatures; it’s too soon to tell.

Paksenarrion fled her rural home because she does not want to marry, ever. She joins one of the companies comprising the mercenary Guild that keeps order in her country, and finds herself in love with the life of a soldier. Though the mercenaries fight for gold, most of the companies keep to a high sense of order and honor, and this appeals to goodhearted Paks. She proves herself a fierce fighter, and earns heroic honors after a brave solo journey across dangerous territory in order to warn her Duke of an impending threat.

Paks has a few brief brushes with the saint Gird, but she’s not particularly religious and Gird isn’t part of the northern belief system. While a prologue hints that Paks’s destiny is one of greatness, the book doesn’t muck about with any “chosen” nonsense. I really liked the workaday aspect of her early journey. She excels, not because she was foretold or some such nonsense, but because she is brave and loyal and true. I like her tremendously.

Tigana by Guy Gavriel Kay

Synopsis:
Tigana is a country that has been obliterated by magic, down to its very name, yet a small group of rebels who remember decide to spark civil war to reclaim the honor of their homeland.

Review:
I wanted to love Tigana, I really did. Guy Gavriel Kay is a beautiful writer, excelling in exploring complex emotions and motivations within scenes that are startlingly original. There are scenes in Tigana that are achingly lovely without sacrificing dramatic impact.

However, the overall story just never clicked for me. I’m willing to give Kay the benefit of the doubt and call it the Sopranos effect–the machinations of the wranglings for power are somewhat lost on me. I’m not one for politics or strategy. I am terrible at chess and am not confident in my ability to guess the motivations of the key players because the source of their actions doesn’t like in their emotions. I don’t traffic in cold calculation and “The Sopranos” always made me feel stupid because I was always way behind the characters. I’m much more comfortable on psychological terrain, and that’s why “Battlestar Galactica” is more my style. The characters play politics, but their politics are always very personal, so I get it.

In Tigana, the main characters are playing an incredibly complicated game as they try to topple the warring sorcerers who have wiped the name of Tigana from the world. Each individual scene was gorgeous and fascinating, but by the time I got to the end I had given up on trying to figure out how it all fit together. Funny enough, that’s also the reason I got a D in AP Physics…

Volume (Booking Through Thursday)

This week’s meme:

Would you say that you read about the same amount now as when you were younger? More? Less? Why?

I have always been a voracious reader. I think the only time in my life I didn’t read much was in my early 20s when I was working 2 fulltime jobs right out of grad school. But I’m sure I still read every day.

In other news, here’s a great interview with Battlestar Galactica creator Ron Moore on what the WGA strike means to him.

Amusing Ourselves to Death by Neil Postman

Synopsis:
We live in the Age of Show Business. Postman’s book is a history of discourse that presents the case for the preeminence of the written word over visual media, and outlines the ills inherent in a visually-driven society.

Review:
I was somewhat familiar with Postman’s general ideas, having been friends with one of his protegees for many years. However, this is the first time I have read him for myself, which is a shame because I have an advanced degree in cinema studies. My studies were focused more on film history and less on film theory, so that’s my justification. Continue reading

Bridge of D’Arnath Series by Carol Berg

Synopsis:
In a world where magic has been forbidden, an evil rises and threatens total destruction unless one young man can step into his destiny and choose the right path.

Review:
I hated to do this, but I stopped reading somewhere around page 300 of the third book of this 4-part series. I came to the realization that I would rather be reading anything else but this book, and given that I have a sizable stack on my bedside table, I decided to cut my losses and move on. Continue reading